From Judgment to Justification: Putting Risk in Dollars – Welcome to Prove It! Utility Asset Management: Decision and Dialogue. Last week we talked about an aging station transformer. Our expert recommended replacement, and our job as asset managers is to estimate whether that is a good idea for other, less technical parties.
Our expert assessed the transformer as “likely” to fail, causing “high” consequences. But we recognized that this didn’t meet our objectives of being transparent and data driven. How can we make it better?
One way is to convert risk from a relative scale into dollars.
But, wait! Most of the risk we hope to avoid is customer outages. Can we put reliability into dollars? Let alone environmental consequences, say, from an oil spill, or even safety. Are we really supposed to express those risks in vulgar dollars?
Remember what we are doing, here. We are helping to make a spending decision: do or do not replace the transformer. Either answer is an implicit statement about how we value risk relative to dollars. “No answer” is not an option, we can only choose whether to be transparent and consistent in our assumptions.
We return to our expert and ask, “Can you help put dollars to this risk? First, what is the probability of failure?”
What happens next will vary. At worst you will guide your SME through an elicitation exercise to pin down what he thinks the odds of a failure really are. Better, you will assemble some data, such as past failures and a fitted curve of failure probability versus age. Let’s say our best estimate is 9%.
For consequences, we need to estimate the subjective cost to our 2000 residential customers and 2 MW of commercial load if the transformer fails and they’re out for 2 hours.
Sources could include the company’s business value framework, published surveys, or even a subjective thought experiment. Write it down, include your max-min range. Ranges are important for sensitivity analysis and for honest communication; precision is less important than honestly about how much you know.
Imagine we estimate the consequence at $630,000–the subjective cost to our customers the outage. Multiplying by 9% probability gives an annual risk of $56,700. (The bases of both of these estimates will be a later topic.)
This seems like a lot of effort. What have we gained? True, we have risk in dollars, but the risk cost does not seem comparable to cost of a new transformer–maybe half a million dollars. Are we any closer to making a decision?
We are. In our next post, we’ll reprise the base case to see how “dollarizing” opens the door. Until then, let me hear about your experience converting risks into dollars. What push-back have you seen from executives or regulators?
image by Hans Hillewaert, CC BY-SA 4.0
#UtilityAssetManagement #ProveItAM #RiskManagement #Risk #BenefitCost #BISConsultingLLC #AssetManagement #ElectricUtilities #WaterUtilities

