Prove It! Week 7: Comparing Benefits and Costs

Prove It! Week 7 — BIS Consulting utility asset management

Tying it all together: comparing benefits and costs – Welcome back to Prove It! a series on utility asset management. We are discussing a business case: should we replace an aging transformer. Our SME estimates that there is a 9% probability the transformer will fail this year, and if it does the cost to our rate payers will be $630,000, for an annual risk of $56,700.

Your instinct may be to compare this to the $500,000 replacement cost, but risk seems too small. Something is not right!

We have lost sight of the problem statement. We were asked, “Should we replace this transformer this year.” Based on that, our base case was 𝘯𝘰𝘵 replacing this year. Maybe we would replace later—our base case is silent on that.

When we compare annual risk to the full replacement cost, we have subtly shifted: we are comparing one year of avoided risk to the full cost of a transformer that might last 60 years. It’s not a fair fight!

To fix things, we could extend the base case into the future, taking credit for avoided risk as the transformer degrades. But this changes our base case from “do not replace this year” to “do not replace ever.”

For our simple business case, there is a simple solution: we should compare one year’s risk to one year’s replacement cost.

What does one year of replacement Cost mean? The key is to ask what we give up if we replace the transformer this year versus not, namely one year’s use of that money. If I don’t replace, I can use it somewhere else, and the lost benefit of whatever else I would have done is the true cost—the opportunity cost—of replacing my transformer today.

How do I estimate this lost opportunity? The discount rate. We always have the option to postpone and instead collect interest on our money equal to the discount rate. If we can’t beat the discount rate, the work should probably be a no-go.

Let’s assume our utility’s discount rate is 5%. This means that the benefit of replacing this year is an avoided risk cost of $56,700, and the cost is that we forego $500,000 x 5% = $25,000 in interest. The benefit/cost ratio is better than 2:1, replacement looks good!

Is this rigorous enough for multi-million-dollar decisions? Probably not. But it does make use of the information available, including the SME’s judgment, and it produces a recommendation that is transparent and defensible, and perfectly suitable for now-or-later decision-making.

Most importantly, this business case is customer focused. We could go to our regulator and show that the cost of this work is in our customers’ best interests. If they understood the situation like we do, they would want us to use rate revenues for it.

Next week, we’ll start going back and shoring up some of the assumptions along the way—especially condition assessment and consequence of failure.

#UtilityAssetManagement #ProveItAM #RiskManagement #Risk #BenefitCost #BISConsultingLLC #AssetManagement #ElectricUtilities #WaterUtilities

Get Prove It! by email

New articles from Darin Johnson on utility asset management, risk and economic life, sent when they are published. Unsubscribe any time.