Prove It! Week 4: The Base Case

Prove It! Week 4 — BIS Consulting utility asset management

Welcome to Prove It! a weekly series exploring utility asset management. This week’s topic is:

The Base Case—key to a good business case

We’re getting to where the rubber meets the road. We’ve talked about the business case as the essence of utility asset management. Today we’ll talk about the single most important step to ensure you are headed in the right direction: a good base case.

Probably you’ve all encountered something like this five-step business case process: 1) problem statement, 2) define options, 3) collect data, 4) analyze, and 5) recommend. There is nothing wrong with this, but it tells us nothing about how to make our business case a good one, not just one that just checks the boxes. How do we do that?

There is one key step in the process that can set you up for success or doom your analysis before it starts: defining the base case. The base case is what you’ll do if you don’t select any of the options on the table. A well-crafted base case is where transparency starts, giving everyone a common perspective.

To see why this is so important, imagine somebody from substation operations says, “Transformer XYZ is showing signs of aging, it has high dissolved gases, and we should replace it.” To figure out whether this is a good idea, I must know what the alternative is – I need a base case. I might be tempted to define the base case as “Do not replace Transformer XYZ,” but that could be a mistake.

Why? Notice that I have introduced a subtle inconsistency between the operator’s recommendation (replace this year) and my base case (do not replace – with no time element). If I compare replacing the transformer today with 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 replacing it, I could be adding up unrealistically high risk costs into the future as the transformer degrades. Replacement might look great, but it’s not a fair fight.

If instead I compare replacing it this year with simply not replacing it this year – focusing on the near term and making no assumption about what happens far in the future – the situation will look different. Replacement may still pencil out, but it’ll be on a level playing field.

In short, if I’m not careful in how I define the base case, I could find myself recommending mitigations that would be more cost effective in a year or two.

Don’t worry if this doesn’t quite snap into focus for you. We will dig into this example more in the upcoming weeks and you’ll get it.

Key takeaways:

• A good base case is the key to a good business case.

• Avoid “now or never” thinking.

• Be realistic – define a base case that matches when you might actually do.

Next week, we’ll roll up our sleeves and build a business case step-by-step, showing how we weave in concepts like health and criticality to prove it.

Can you share how a fuzzy base case has led to a bad call?

#UtilityAssetManagement #ProveITAM #RiskManagement #Risk #BenefitCost #BISConsultingLLC #AssetManagement #ElectricUtilities #WaterUtilities

Get Prove It! by email

New articles from Darin Johnson on utility asset management, risk and economic life, sent when they are published. Unsubscribe any time.