Asset Management Lesson Learned: A Water Utility

Asset Management Lesson Learned — BIS Consulting utility asset management

“A Water Utility” Welcome back to Prove It! A Utility Asset Management series. This is the second anecdote from asset management applications, the first to describe a lesson learned.

It might be a bit sensitive, so I won’t say who was involved. But the story is worth hearing.

My client was the lead engineer at a municipal water utility, a dedicated asset manager who brought my team in to help optimize replacement of water mains. How likely is this pipe to fail? If it fails, what happens? When does risk rise to the point where replacement is attractive?

We collected data, fitted curves, defined failure scenarios, and gathered cost estimates. The results were great—except one thing: there was no recommended replacement program. The prudent thing for now was to keep fixing leaks and use capital resources elsewhere.

This was good news! Right?

Wrong.

It contradicted the narrative the utility had already taken to its board, that there was a looming “bow wave” replacements. Ramping up of spending—and rates—had already begun. The prospect of a U-turn was uncomfortable to contemplate.

Eventually the whole topic was dropped. While it was still being debated, however, no one suggested an input or assumption our team had gotten wrong—failure probability too low, consequence cost understated—that would have changed the result. The result was difficult, not wrong.

I had a similar experience early in my career while working with a regulated electric utility. I did a cost/benefit analysis of cable replacement which suggested they could cut their program way back. I scanned the audience, expecting praise for identifying savings, but instead saw a bunch of people—all of whom understood how utilities make their money—looking uncomfortably at the ceiling.

I remember once reading testimony from another consultant on behalf of his client to support a regulatory request for an increased capital budget. Opposing counsel asked, “Have you ever recommended a 𝑠𝑚𝑎𝑙𝑙𝑒𝑟 capital budget?” He hemmed and hawed a bit but finally admitted he had not. I would have had a good answer to that question, but of course I’d never have been asked to testify!

There are two key takeaways here. First, be sure you understand your audience’s expectations so you can work with them to navigate any surprises. The second may be even more important: keep an open mind to the possibility that What Everybody Knows may be wrong.

We should have an aggressive replacement program. We have low wildfire risk. Our nation’s infrastructure is crumbling.

Maybe, maybe not. Sometimes culture and inertia can set us down the wrong path. Finding a way to correct course in the ratepayers’ interest is as important as making good decisions in the first place.

Look at it this way, if asset management only ever confirmed what you already believe, what was the point?

How BIS applies this in practice: water and wastewater asset management.

Get Prove It! by email

New articles from Darin Johnson on utility asset management, risk and economic life, sent when they are published. Unsubscribe any time.