Prove It! Week 15: Building the Team

Prove It! Week 15 — BIS Consulting utility asset management

Welcome back to Prove It! Utility Asset Management: Decision and Dialogue. n this installment we will discuss forming an asset management team: what should its role be, what skills must be represented, and where does it lie in the org chart?

Asset management works best when it is properly situated within the organization. It should be its own function rather than an offshoot of engineering, planning, or operations. In fact, it should be a peer to those groups, on equal footing ad with independent responsibilities.

Why is this placement best? Remember how our goal is to help technical experts communicate with finance and regulatory? This only works if asset management is positioned so that its recommendations carry weight. Also, creating separating between asset management and the “doers” maintains impartiality when a decision pits interests against one another.

What should the asset management group do? It will come as no surprise that my answer is business cases. The process by which a project is approved and funded should be something like this. First, somebody in planning, engineering, or operations comes up with an idea: “We should do this to improve reliability,” “If we quit doing that, we’ll save money,” or, “We should upgrade those obsolete things.” Next asset management swings into action, asking questions such as, “Define precisely what it is you are proposing,” “Explain the benefits in terms of customer value,” and “What is the base case—if we don’t take your advice, what happens?” The asset manager uses the tools of the trade, such as risk assessment and life-cycle cost analysis, to quantify the answers. Finally, the business case with recommendation is attached to the proposal and is sent to the budgeting and regulatory processes. It may not be impossible to get a project or program funded without a thumbs-up from asset management, but it requires an explanation why in this circumstance we wish to spend some of our resources in a way that—at least at first glance—does not make the pie bigger. Who should be on the asset management team? Utilities and similar agencies are chock-full of engineers, and it’s a good bet that your first asset managers will be engineers, too. That’s okay, but you should actively seek opportunities to bring other perspectives to the table: finance, economics, even people with little or no background in the utility industry.

Look for people with a skeptical bent, who don’t mind pushing back and asking dumb questions, and who are willing to stand firm when their analysis disappoints a strong-willed SME. “Prove it!” This is the essence of the asset manager’s job. In the coming weeks, we will consider some asset management success stories and a few lessons learned.

Get Prove It! by email

New articles from Darin Johnson on utility asset management, risk and economic life, sent when they are published. Unsubscribe any time.